Shepherd Insurance - Membership Directory Go back to directory. Shepherd Insurance Shepherd Insurance Business 222 E Main St Carmi Illinois 62821 work Business Phone: 618-216-1162work Website: Shepherd Insurance Related by Category Kati Sturgal – Shelter Insurance 618-382-8930work KSturgal@ShelterInsurance.comINTERNET Dave Matheny State Farm 618-382-7383work Trudee Wynn – Country Financial 618-963-2621work trudee.wynn@countryfinancial.comINTERNET J Cook Insurance Agency, Inc. 618-382-7381work Cox Financial 812-471-2210work First Bank 1-800-538-3979work TweetPinShare0 Shares